Deliverable Review Form
Identification of the deliverable or milestone |
Project: EMI |
Deliverable or milestone identifier: DNA1.1 |
Title: Project Quality Assurance and Progress Monitoring Plan |
Doc. identifier: EMI-DNA1.1-CDSREF-Project_QA_Plan-v0_5 |
Author(s): Alberto Di Meglio (NA1, CERN), Florida Estrella (NA1, CERN) |
Due date: PM1 (May 2010) |
Identification of the reviewer |
Name: Alberto Aimar |
Affiliation: CERN |
EMI Activity: SA2 |
Review date |
20/07/2010 |
Author(s) revision date |
10/08/2010 |
Reviewer acceptance date |
11/08/2010 |
Attach the reviewed document to the deliverable page, put here a link
General comments
The document is good. There are a few comments and requests of clarification inside the document itself. I think they should be answered adding a few explanations where requested.
Additional recommendations (not affecting the document content, e.g. recommendation for future work)
None
Detailed comments on the content
Note 1: The reviewers must list here any observation they want to track explicitly and that require interaction with the authors
Note 2: These comments have to be explicitly addressed by the authors and the action taken must be clearly described
*ALL COMMENTS ARE IN THE DOCUMENT. I IS EXTREMELY INEFFICIENT TO COPY AND PASTE INTO THE WIKI. IS NOT GOOD FOR AUTHOURS NOR FOR REVIEWERS. WE SHOULD CHANGE THIS FORM ASAP. PLEASE... *
N° |
Page |
Section |
Observations |
Reply |
Is Addressed? |
1 |
|
|
All comments in the document have been taken into account -- AlbertoDiMeglio - 10-Aug-2010 |
|