IFAE 2015 proceedings: poster on development and performance of Triple-GEM detectors
Proceedings
Communication with coll., feedback on proceedings
- Date of circulation to GEM coll. 16/07/2015
Comments about author list
The maximum length foreseen for this proceeding was 2 pages. However, since the CMS GEM author list is more than 1 page long, I would try to go for a three page long paper, as for the Elba proceedings.
Comments by Paul Karchin (24/07/2015)
- I think it would be reasonable to add another page of material since the collaboration list takes up most of two pages. The paper should be 2 page-long and I am already one page longer, so I prefer not to add other additional pages.
- In a paper this short, there is no need for section headings. Done
- The Summary should be more specific. Give the main results. As the paper is so short, if I add more detail in the summary I would essentially repeat what I have written in the paper. So I prefer not to modify it.
- The only figure shows a result that I guess is rather old, even if it appears in the TDR. It may have been reported in much earlier conference proceedings. It would be more interesting to show a more recent result using arge area chambers. Done
Comments by ...
--
IlariaVai - 2015-07-11